Three different colors of felt.
One shoe lace (at least 32 inches long)
Simplicity Pattern 3709
I used a pattern for this page. I had it on hand and found it easier than creating my own shoe. So just follow the instructions in the pattern.
I used a small punch to get the holes for the grommets. I don't know if you really need grommets-but I think it gives it extra strength.
The grommets also help it look more like a shoe.
If I were to do this page over again I would cut the laces just a little bit longer. They need another two inches to make it easier for little hands to tie a bow.